Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Wind Child, Shirley Rousseau Murphy, Leo & Diane Dillon

Wind Child, Shirley Rousseau Murphy, Leo & Diane Dillon.
ISBN: 006024903X
Read September 13, 2013
Picture book.

The wind fell in love with a lady, and she died in childbirth, so in his grief he left the infant with an old lady and never looked for her or cared about her afterwards.  Meanwhile, the half-wind child (and young lady) didn't fit in on the earth, worked as a celebrated weaver, dreamed about flying, didn't like any earth-based men, and tried to construct more suitable lovers/partners for herself out of the elements, until a prince of the wind noticed her and carried her off into the sky with him.

Very odd.  I can't decide if the distant tone of the writing or the formal and aloof nature of the artwork is more offputting.  I would think something like this would be right up my alley, but it's really not.  I'm a bit sad about that.  Something is just really off about this work, and it just doesn't work for me.  

I do like that the townsfolk are effortlessly multicultural, and her "constructed" men are beautifully illustrated, but the Prince is dressed laughably - his capelet is just not well-fitted to the character.

The artwork is beautiful, if a little stiff and cold, and the story itself has no real objectionable elements - the heroine is self-possessed, creative, hard-working, and quick-witted, so there's that.  Just didn't resonate with me.  Sadly, this one's a miss.

No comments:

Post a Comment